There has been a long-running dispute amongst comic fans over who is the better newspaper editor--Perry White or J. Jonah Jameson. (OK, there hasn't actually been debate--but it sounds better if I pretend there has been!)
We, the answer is--neither!! In case you zoned out during last week's Fawcett 1941 Week, I made the astonishing character find of 2011--Burton!!
Starring (yes, starring--no supporting character is Burton!!) in The Devil's Dagger strip in Master Comics #1-#20, Burton was the editor of the Carterville Daily Blade, and he made J. Jonah Jameson look like he was on Prozac.
He had two obsessions--uncovering the identity of Carterville's mysterious master villain, Mr. H, and uncovering the identity of Carterville's mysterious hero--the dashing Devil's Dagger.
I won't point out that BOTH of those people actually worked for him as reporters...that would be uncharitable.
Burton was never given a first name--such a titanic figure needs only one name, for who else could you be talking about when you say "Burton"?
He also apparently had some type of mutant powers, because every time you saw him, papers would start to fly about uncontrollably:
Burton was also a bit...demanding of his star reporter, Ken Wyman (who was also the Devil's Dagger--shhh!):
And did I mention that Burton was a tiny bit excitable?
J. Jonah Jameson wishes he could get that worked up...
Burton appeared in comics before Perry White (but one month after Perry had debuted on Superman's radio show), and obviously he was around 20 some years before Jameson stalked the landscape. So, yes, he's old school.
But since DC presumably owns him, why not bring Burton into the 21st century, and make him editor of The Daily Planet in the New New (New) DC Universe? He's used to being befuddled by having someone with a secret identity working for him...
...he's got a drive and energy to bring in the fans...
...and substitute "Kent" for "Wyman" in all those balloons, and your good to go!!
Burton--the editor we all need!!
If the competition was just between Perry and Jonah, no contest, it's Perry. The Daily Planet is a respected newspaper, while the Bugle runs all these crazy anti-Spider-Man stories. Jimmy Olsen is a staff photographer. Peter Parker is treated like paparazzi. So yeah, the Bugle always seemed like a tabloid to me. And in the area of human resources, well... again, pretty obvious.
ReplyDeleteBurton in the new DCU? I have a feeling they're giving Lois that job...
"Remember your liver"? Is Burton having an alcohol fueled meltdown?
ReplyDeleteJolly Jonah, any day of the week.
ReplyDeleteSure, he's the world's worst boss, and sure, his Spider-Man vendetta is... yeah.
But he's also an honest newsman and good at his job, ignoring the Spider-Man thing. Pushed for civil rights, treats mutants like people, publishes the truth about Wilson Fisk.
Heck, he even prints retractions for the Spidey headlines, as much as it pains him, when they inevitably come up false.
And any man with the guts to go up to Godzilla and insult him from five inches away? That's the guy I'm backing.
(Also, Perry White's unpublished novel is the worst thing ever.)
Arguments in Perry's favor: What JJJ does for Kingpin, Perry does for Luthor. And hey, super-powered cigars. SUPER-POWERED CIGARS!!!!
ReplyDelete